} } } }

It's Not Necessary

Condividi
54
26 / 54

It's Not Necessary


A few days ago I was on a plane. I'm finally in Dubai.


You know that moment when the plane is already up, the lights are low, your phone has no signal and you have nothing left to do but think? That's it. In that moment I started counting how many flights I'd taken this year.


I was counting them with a certain sense of guilt, like when you look at your bank statement at the end of the month and every line asks you to explain yourself. Because looking at them one by one, on paper, almost none of them were indispensable. I could have stayed home. I could have done a call. I could have pushed it back a month, and the world would have gone on just the same.


And while I was counting, a voice started up in my head. A voice I know very well and hadn't heard in years. The voice said:


"It's not necessary."


Three words. And in a second I was no longer on that plane. I was in my parents' kitchen, ten years old, with a request on the tip of my tongue.


I was a child who wanted to do everything. Maybe too much.


One year it was the skateboard. I wanted it more than anything else in the world, I'd think about it at night before falling asleep. The year after it was skiing. Then something else, and then something else again. Every time I saw someone doing something I didn't know, the same light switched on inside me: I want to try.


And the truth, the one I didn't know how to put into words back then, is that I had no interest in becoming a champion at anything. I was interested in knowing what it felt like. I'd try something, stay inside it until I felt satisfied, until I'd understood what there was to understand, and then I'd move on to the next thing. I never made it all the way to the end. I made it all the way to my end.


Only at ten years old you have no power. It's not like you walk into a shop and buy yourself a skateboard. You have no money, no voice, no signature. You have just one thing: you can ask.


And I would ask. I would ask all the time.


And the answer, almost always, was that one.


"It's not necessary."


Two voices, one phrase


My mother said it and my father said it. Same phrase, word for word. But they were two completely different phrases.


My mother said it bluntly, without appeal, like a door slamming in your face while you're still talking. There was no room to argue back.


My father said it with more silence, almost with a kind of unease. The result was the same, the skateboard never came, but it arrived in a different way.


It's the phrase I hated most as a child. More than any scolding, more than any punishment. Because a punishment at least tells you what you did wrong. This one didn't. This one told you that the problem was you, that you wanted things nobody needed. That you wanted too much.


What was underneath


And here is the point of this letter. Which isn't the phrase. It's what was underneath it.


Because the things we say are almost never what we mean to say. They're a lid. We set them down over something we can't bring ourselves to say out loud, and we hope nobody lifts it.


Underneath that "it's not necessary," most of the time, there was:


We can't afford it.


We know you'll buy it and then get bored.


It's just a passing phase.


And I'm not telling you this as the great discovery of adulthood. I always knew it. Even at ten, deep down, I knew perfectly well. Children always know everything, they just don't have the words for it.


But there's something I understood later, and it's the thing that hits me the most.


My mother's sharpness wasn't directed at me. It was the desire to say yes, and the impossibility of doing so. It was the frustration of having to say no to your child over something small, something that in another house would have been a yes without a second thought. That anger was hers, against the situation, against the accounts that didn't add up. Except you can't look a situation in the face. You can look at your child. And so it landed on me.


And that is the problem with lid-phrases: what you say and what arrives are never the same thing.


My mother said "we can't."


What I heard was "what you want is too much."


Too much compared to what


It took me years to ask myself the right question about that word.


Too much compared to what?


Who decides what's too much? Who decided it was wrong to try skateboarding for a year, then skiing, then something else again? Why can't you try ten sports, ten instruments, ten trades, until you find yours? And then, why do you have to find just one? Who wrote the rule that you have to choose one thing and stay inside it for life? Can't you be reasonably good at a lot of things?


Nobody ever explained it to me. It just landed on me, along with that phrase. One of those phrases people say to you once, maybe without even thinking, and you end up believing. And by believing it long enough it stops being someone else's phrase and becomes yours. It becomes what you think you are.


They're called curses. Damned phrases, and we're all full of them.


Mine was: you never finish anything.


I'll talk to you about that one another time, because it deserves a letter of its own. I'll just say that it was born exactly there, from the child who wanted to try everything and from a home where every attempt cost something that wasn't there.


The skateboard did eventually arrive, by the way. And it arrived the way almost everything arrived, from then on. Either by fighting far too hard for something far too simple. Or by working, and paying for it myself.


Today I look at everything differently.


The problem isn't that those things were necessary. The problem is the word "necessary."


Because if you think about it, almost nothing is necessary. Eating, sleeping, breathing. Everything else is a choice. The sport, the trip, the book, the dinner out, the course you won't finish. None of that is necessary, and none of it is pointless. It depends on who you are, how you're made, your habits, what keeps you standing. What's indispensable for me is superfluous for you, and the other way around. We all have different habits, and so there's no universal list of necessary things.


So "necessary" is the wrong question. It's a fake tribunal, where the verdict is already written before you even open your mouth.


There's no such thing as necessary and not necessary. There's an honest assessment: do I want to do this thing, yes or no? And why? For the fun of it, out of stubbornness, out of curiosity, for any other reason at all. All of that is fine. As long as you look the reason in the face and weigh it for what it is.


But who is truly capable of weighing their own decisions? And above all, where do yours come from?


Our behaviors seem so right to us, yet they come from phrases so old that we've often forgotten them. And we end up spending our whole lives stuck in the belief that we're not necessary, or that we're not enough. (There are also people who think they're too much and the center of the world, let's not forget. In this letter I'm speaking to the desperate ones like me, but the inflated ones are out there too.)


Because the opposite risk exists, and it's the one I risk falling into: spending your life saying yes to everything just to prove a phrase you heard as a child wrong. That too is letting that phrase decide for you. Just in reverse.


Now let's go back to my flights.


This time without the voice from home in my head, and with the right question instead of the wrong one. Not "was it necessary?" but "did I want it, and why?"


And I understood something that almost made me laugh to myself, sitting there.


None of those flights was necessary. But they were all right.


Those are two different words, and for years I confused them. Necessary is what the world imposes on you. The new cut, the new trousers, the new look: those things are necessary if you want to keep up.


Right, on the other hand, is what you choose, knowing why you're choosing it.


Before I let you go


Nobody has said that phrase to me for many years now. But I've noticed that every now and then I say it to myself. In my mother's voice, sometimes. In my father's, at others.


And when it happens now I do one thing: I lift the lid. I ask myself what's underneath. Because almost never is it true that something serves no purpose. Usually there's something else underneath. I can't. I'm afraid. I don't have time. I'm not sure I deserve it.


So here's this week's question.


Think about the last time you told yourself "it's not necessary." About something you wanted, even something small.


Now lift the lid. What was underneath?


If underneath it is truly "I'm not interested," then let it go. But if there's something else there, that is the real phrase. And that's the one you need to reckon with, not the other one.


Fifty-four attempts to become better. This is the twenty-sixth. Best, Stefano.

If you feel like it, reply to this email and tell me. I read every single one, myself.

Fifty-four attempts to become better.
54letter.com

Unsubscribe